We don't often write about Climate Change - our last piece on this topic was more than a year ago - not for any lack of passion about the subject, but mostly because we take the view epitomized in this cartoon that was being "shared" on Facebook this month by the League of Conservation Voters:
Solar has the potential to make the world - and your bottom line - better regardless of your politics and hence that is our focus.
But late last month a story broke that is so significant that it merits at least a passing reference.
Richard Muller is a physicist at U.C. Berkeley and for the past several years he has gained a certain notoriety by his public displays of skepticism regarding the science of climate change. In particular, he questioned the reliability of the temperate data itself - the very predicate upon which the climate change models are built. Climate change deniers seized on his skepticism: if the data are no good, then the conclusions drawn from that data cannot be any good either. For example, here is climate change denier Fred Singer praising Prof. Muller's efforts - before the results were announced:
The Berkeley Earth Surface Temperature (BEST) Project aims to do what needs to be done: That is, to develop an independent analysis of the data from land stations, which would include many more stations than had been considered by the Global Historic Climatology Network. The Project is in the hands of a group of recognized scientists, who are not at all "climate skeptics" — which should enhance their credibility. The Project is mainly directed by physicists, chaired by Professor Richard Muller (UC Berkeley), with a steering group that includes Professor Judith Curry (Georgia Tech) and Arthur Rosenfeld (UC Santa Barbara and Georgia Tech).
I applaud and support what is being done by the Project – a very difficult but important undertaking. I personally have little faith in the quality of the surface data, having been exposed to the revealing work by Anthony Watts and others. However, I have an open mind on the issue and look forward to seeing the results of the Project in their forthcoming publications.
As far as I know, no government or industry funds are involved – at least at this stage. According to the Project’s website www.berkeleyearth.org, support comes mostly from a group of charitable foundations.
(See full article here.)
As it turns out, a significant chunk of the funding from a "charitable foundation" came from the Charles G. Koch Charitable Foundation - the funder of first resort for climate change deniers across the country. Put most simply - the denier community was expecting the Koch-sponsored Project to slay the climate change dragon.
Didn't happen that way.
Instead, Prof. Muller's painstaking analysis, first released last Fall, demonstrated that the temperature data was solid and that the Earth was warming. Then, at the end of July, Muller published an Op-Ed piece in the New York Times. Titled, The Conversion of a Climate Change Skeptic, the piece takes on the denialists in no uncertain terms:
Call me a converted skeptic. Three years ago I identified problems in previous climate studies that, in my mind, threw doubt on the very existence of global warming. Last year, following an intensive research effort involving a dozen scientists, I concluded that global warming was real and that the prior estimates of the rate of warming were correct. I'm now going a step further: Humans are almost entirely the cause.
Snap.
Rachel Maddow interviewed Prof. Muller (video below) and it was interesting to watch from a number of perspectives. The key point - that climate change is real and humans are the cause - came through. But rather than call for policy that would provide real relief, he threw in with the oil and gas industry and supported "clean" fracking, which is a bit like supporting "clean coal" in that neither one exists.
The denialists might have lost their last great hope, but the oil and gas industry is far from calling it a day in favor of carbon-neutral technology. Sadly, Prof. Muller appears to be ready to lend them a hand.
|